When you are dealing with an insurance claim in Florida, one of the most fundamental questions is whether you are filing a first-party claim or a third-party claim. The distinction sounds technical, but it affects everything about how your claim is handled: which insurer you deal with, what coverage applies, how the settlement is calculated, what deadlines you face, and what legal remedies are available if the insurer does not treat you fairly.
Many Florida residents carry both types of coverage without fully understanding the difference. After a car accident, for example, you may be filing a first-party PIP claim with your own insurer while simultaneously pursuing a third-party bodily injury claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance. After a hurricane, you may file a first-party homeowners claim with your own carrier while also pursuing a third-party claim against a contractor whose negligent work contributed to the damage.
Ilabaca Law, PLLC handles both first-party and third-party insurance disputes throughout Florida. Understanding which type of claim you are dealing with is the first step toward an effective legal strategy.
What Is a First-Party Insurance Claim?
A first-party claim is a claim you file with your own insurance company under your own policy. You paid the premiums. You have a contract with the insurer. Now you are asking the insurer to pay benefits that your policy promises.
The name “first-party” comes from insurance contract terminology. You are the “first party” to the contract. Your insurance company is the “second party.” When you file a claim under your own policy, you are making a first-party demand against the second party to the contract.
Common first-party claims in Florida include:
Homeowners insurance claims for property damage caused by hurricanes, fire, water damage, wind, hail, lightning, and other covered perils. When a storm tears off your roof and you file a claim with your homeowners insurer, that is a first-party claim.
Auto insurance PIP claims. Florida’s Personal Injury Protection coverage pays your own medical bills and lost wages after a car accident, regardless of who caused the crash. Because you are claiming benefits under your own auto policy, PIP is a first-party claim.
Auto insurance collision and comprehensive claims. If your vehicle is damaged in an accident (collision) or by a non-collision event like theft, vandalism, or a falling tree (comprehensive), you file a claim under your own policy. These are first-party claims.
Uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) claims. When the driver who caused your accident has no insurance or insufficient insurance, your own UM/UIM coverage steps in. Even though the other driver caused the accident, you are filing the claim with your own insurer under your own policy, making it a first-party claim.
Flood insurance claims filed under your own NFIP or private flood policy.
Business interruption claims under your own commercial property policy.
The defining feature of a first-party claim is the contractual relationship between you and the insurer. You have a contract (the insurance policy) that specifies what the insurer promised to pay and under what conditions. When the insurer denies or underpays a valid claim, it is breaching that contract.
What Is a Third-Party Insurance Claim?
A third-party claim is a claim you file against someone else’s insurance policy. Another person or entity (the “first party” to their insurance contract) caused your injury or damage. Their insurer (the “second party” to that contract) is the company you are seeking payment from. You are the “third party,” an outsider to the insurance contract, seeking compensation from it.
Common third-party claims in Florida include:
Bodily injury liability claims against the at-fault driver’s auto insurance after a car accident. If another driver runs a red light and hits you, you pursue a claim against their bodily injury liability coverage. You have no contract with their insurer; you are a third party claiming against their policy.
Liability claims against property owners after a slip and fall or other premises liability incident. When you are injured on someone else’s property due to a dangerous condition, you pursue a claim against the property owner’s liability insurance.
Claims against businesses or manufacturers for injuries caused by defective products, negligent services, or unsafe premises.
Claims against contractors, subcontractors, or professionals whose negligent work caused property damage or personal injury.
The defining feature of a third-party claim is that you do not have a contractual relationship with the insurer you are pursuing. The insurer’s obligations run to its own policyholder (the at-fault party), not to you. This has important implications for how the claim is handled and what legal remedies are available.
Key Differences That Affect Your Case
Understanding the differences between first-party and third-party claims helps you (and your attorney) develop the right strategy for your situation.
Your relationship with the insurer. In a first-party claim, the insurer owes you contractual duties of good faith, fair dealing, prompt investigation, and timely payment. These duties are spelled out in your policy and reinforced by Florida statutes like §627.70131 (claims processing timelines). In a third-party claim, the insurer does not owe those duties to you. Their obligations are to their own policyholder.
Bad faith remedies. This is one of the most significant practical differences.
In first-party bad faith, your own insurer fails to handle your claim fairly. You can pursue a statutory bad faith claim under Florida Statute §624.155, which requires written notice to the insurer detailing the specific violation and a 90-day cure period before you can file suit. If the bad faith claim succeeds, you can recover damages beyond the policy limits.
In third-party bad faith, the at-fault party’s insurer fails to settle a clear liability claim within its own insured’s policy limits, exposing its insured to a judgment that exceeds those limits. Third-party bad faith claims in Florida are based on common law rather than statute. They typically arise when the insurer ignores a reasonable settlement demand, and a jury subsequently awards damages that exceed the policy limits. The insured (the at-fault party) may then assign their bad faith claim to the injured person.
Statutes of limitations. The deadlines are different. First-party claims for breach of insurance contract have a five-year statute of limitations from the date of loss. Third-party personal injury claims (negligence-based) have a two-year statute of limitations under HB 837, for claims arising on or after March 24, 2023.
Types of damages. In first-party claims, you recover the value of the covered loss under your policy (repair costs, lost income, ALE, etc.), and in bad faith cases, consequential damages caused by the insurer’s misconduct. In third-party claims, you can recover economic damages (medical bills, lost wages, property damage), non-economic damages (pain and suffering, emotional distress), and potentially punitive damages.
Comparative negligence. Third-party claims are subject to Florida’s modified comparative negligence standard. If you are found more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover. First-party claims are contract-based and are generally not subject to comparative negligence (though the insurer may raise other contractual defenses).
Dispute resolution options. First-party property insurance claims can often be resolved through the policy’s appraisal clause or the Florida Department of Financial Services’ mediation program. Third-party claims are resolved through negotiation, litigation, or trial.
When You Have Both Types of Claims
Many Florida incidents involve both first-party and third-party claims simultaneously:
Car accidents. You file a first-party PIP claim with your own insurer for immediate medical bills and lost wages. If your injuries are serious enough to meet the serious injury threshold, you also pursue a third-party bodily injury claim against the at-fault driver’s liability insurance. If the at-fault driver is uninsured, you may file a first-party UM claim with your own insurer.
Hurricane damage. You file a first-party homeowners claim for wind damage to your property. If a contractor’s negligent work (such as a poorly installed roof or improperly sealed windows) contributed to the damage, you may also have a third-party negligence claim against the contractor.
Premises liability. If you slip and fall at a business, you may file a third-party liability claim against the property owner’s insurance. If your injuries require emergency medical care and you have auto insurance with PIP (and the fall was not auto-related), your health insurance is the primary payer, but the dynamics of claim coordination still matter.
Managing multiple claims from the same incident requires careful coordination. Settlements in one claim can affect the other, and accepting a third-party settlement may require reimbursing your own insurer for first-party benefits already paid (a process called subrogation). An attorney experienced in handling overlapping claims ensures you do not inadvertently compromise one claim while settling the other.
Why the Distinction Matters for Your Legal Strategy
The first-party/third-party distinction determines which legal theories apply, what evidence you need, what deadlines govern your case, and what remedies are available if the insurer acts unfairly. A strategy that works for a third-party negligence claim (proving fault, documenting damages, negotiating with the at-fault party’s insurer) is fundamentally different from a strategy for a first-party contract dispute (proving the loss is covered, challenging the insurer’s denial, invoking appraisal or bad faith remedies).
An attorney who handles both types of claims can evaluate your situation holistically, identify all available insurance coverage, and develop a coordinated strategy that maximizes your total recovery.
Contact Ilabaca Law About Your Insurance Claim
Whether you are fighting your own insurer over a denied homeowners claim or pursuing compensation from another party’s liability coverage, Ilabaca Law, PLLC can help. We handle both first-party and third-party insurance disputes throughout Florida and fight for fair outcomes regardless of which side of the insurance contract you are on.
Contact us at (407) 917-2087 or schedule a free consultation online to discuss your insurance claim.
This page provides general information about first-party and third-party insurance claims in Florida and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is different, and you should consult with a qualified attorney about the specific facts of your case.


